Visit Our Store
Visit Buttercup’s Dairy Store and experience the best in fresh, locally sourced products and delicious daily specials. Conveniently located at the corner of Boyle Road and Old Town Road in Port Jefferson Station, we’re here to serve all your grocery and deli needs. Stop by today and see why Buttercup’s has been a neighborhood favorite for generations!
Home to Long Island’s favorite pies, baked fresh daily with love!
Our Long Island Famous Pies
At Buttercup’s Dairy Store, our made-in-house pies are the perfect blend of tradition and flavor. With over 20 delicious variations to choose from, there’s something to satisfy every craving. From classic favorites to seasonal specialties, each pie is handcrafted with care and baked fresh daily. Stop in and treat yourself to a slice of homemade goodness or pick up a whole pie to share with friends and family!
Visit With Kids
Buttercup Day is almost here, and it’s our favorite way to give back to the community we love! Enjoy a day full of fun and excitement with activities like a mechanical bull, petting zoo, pony rides, $1 hot dogs, and free kids’ games with prizes. Located right in the big field at Buttercup’s Dairy Store, it’s the perfect way to bring family and friends together for an unforgettable celebration!
- Follow us on social media for all the latest Buttercup Day updates!
Our Community Care
At Buttercup’s Dairy Store, our community is at the heart of everything we do. From hosting fun-filled events like Buttercup Day to offering fresh, locally sourced products, we’re dedicated to supporting and giving back to the people who make our store so special. We take pride in being a gathering place for families, neighbors, and friends, creating memories and connections that last a lifetime. Caring for our community isn’t just part of our mission—it’s who we are!
Make sure you tag us on social:
#ButtercupDairy
How to Find Us
You can find us at 285 Boyle Road, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776. We’re conveniently located near the intersection of Boyle Road and Old Town Road, just minutes from major roads in the area. Look for our big field—it’s the perfect spot to stop by for fresh goods and community events like Buttercup Day!
Business Hours
Monday 8am to 7pm
Tuesday 8am to 7pm
Wednesday 8am to 7pm
Thursday 8am to 7pm
Friday 8am to 7pm
Saturday 8am to 6pm
Sunday 8am to 6pm