Bakery
Our bakery at Buttercup’s Dairy Store is a haven for fresh, homemade goodness. From warm, soft cookies to our famous pies made in-house with over 20 delicious variations, every treat is baked with care and the finest ingredients. Whether you’re craving a sweet snack or looking for the perfect dessert to share, our bakery offers something for everyone to enjoy!
Filter by:
Shop Other
Filter by:
Shop Other
Showing 1–9 of 48 results
-
Click to call and place order10” Apple Crumb Pie
$14.99 -
Click to call and place order10” Apple Pie
$10.99 -
Click to call and place order10” Blueberry Crumb Pie
$16.99 -
Click to call and place order10” Cherry Crumb Pie
$16.99 -
Click to call and place order10” Coconut Custard Pie
$12.99 -
Click to call and place order -
Click to call and place order8” Apple Pie
$7.99 -
Click to call and place order8” Blueberry Pie
$7.99 -
Click to call and place order8” Cherry Pie
$7.99