Shop Online & Pick Up
Enjoy the convenience of shopping from home and picking up your order at our store at a time that works for you! Simply browse our online selection, place your order, and choose a pickup time that fits your schedule. We’ll have everything ready for you when you arrive—no waiting, no hassle. Shop now and experience an easy, seamless pickup process!
Today's Specials
Call ahead to place your deli orders to have them ready when you arrive.
Visit us at the corner of Boyle Road and Old Town Road in Port Jefferson Station and check back often for updated deals and fresh picks. Store hours run weekdays and weekends with plenty of time to stop in!
Discover the Best of Buttercup's Daily Specials
Freshly Made Delights
Enjoy a full deli featuring Boar's Head products, including pre-cut and pre-wrapped cold cuts, paired with a variety of heat-and-eat meals for quick, delicious dinners.
Seasonal Bakery Specials
Explore our full bakery with freshly baked pies, rolls, breads, cookies, and cakes, perfect for any occasion or everyday indulgence.
Locally Sourced Produce
Stock up on fresh produce, including locally grown fruits and vegetables, to complement your meals with farm-fresh flavor.
Convenience and Variety
From dairy essentials like milk, eggs, and butter to grocery staples such as canned goods and baking supplies, we offer everything you need for your weekly shopping in one stop.