• Home
  • Shop Store
    • Bakery
    • Pies
    • Deli Meats & Cheeses
    • Deli Salads
    • Produce
    • Catering
  • Daily Specials
  • Weekly Specials
  • About
  • Visit
  • Store Hours
  • Home
  • Shop Store
    • Bakery
    • Pies
    • Deli Meats & Cheeses
    • Deli Salads
    • Produce
    • Catering
  • Daily Specials
  • Weekly Specials
  • About
  • Visit
  • Store Hours
$0.00 0 Cart

(631) 928-4607

(631) 928-4607

  • Home
  • Shop Store
    • Shop Store
    • Bakery
    • Pies
    • Deli Meats & Cheeses
    • Deli Salads
    • Produce
    • Catering
  • Daily Specials
  • Weekly Specials
  • About
  • Visit
  • Store Hours
  • Home
  • Shop Store
    • Shop Store
    • Bakery
    • Pies
    • Deli Meats & Cheeses
    • Deli Salads
    • Produce
    • Catering
  • Daily Specials
  • Weekly Specials
  • About
  • Visit
  • Store Hours

Uncategorized

Filter by:
Shop Other
  • All
  • Bakery
  • Pies
  • Deli Meats & Cheeses
  • Deli Salads
  • Produce
  • Catering
  • All
  • Bakery
  • Pies
  • Deli Meats & Cheeses
  • Deli Salads
  • Produce
  • Catering
Filter by:
Bakery Products
  • Breads (1)
  • Cookies (2)
  • Muffins (3)
  • Pies (2)
Shop Other
  • All
  • Bakery
  • Pies
  • Deli Meats & Cheeses
  • Deli Salads
  • Produce
  • Catering
  • All
  • Bakery
  • Pies
  • Deli Meats & Cheeses
  • Deli Salads
  • Produce
  • Catering

Showing 1–9 of 31 results

  • 8” Peach Pie

    8” Peach Pie

     $7.99
    Click to call and place order
  • 9” Bumbleberry Pie

    9” Bumbleberry Pie

     $16.99
    Click to call and place order
  • Almond Joy Cookies

    Almond Joy Cookies
    Click to call and place order
  • Blueberry Muffins

    Blueberry Muffins
    Click to call and place order
  • Chocolate Chip Muffins

    Chocolate Chip Muffins
    Click to call and place order
  • Cranberry White Chocolate Cookies

    Cranberry White Chocolate Cookies
    Click to call and place order
  • Egg Twist Rolls

    Egg Twist Rolls

     $3.29
    Click to call and place order
  • Placeholder

    Grab n Go Store Cooked Brazilian Roast Beef Special (Thursday)

     $5.49
    Click to call and place order
  • Placeholder

    Grab n Go Store Cooked Brazilian Roast Beef Special (Tuesday)

     $5.49
    Click to call and place order
Page 1 of 41 2 3 4 Next

Real Reviews From Real Customers

Excellent

 Rated 4.8 out of 5

Based on

90+ Reviews 

 Rated 5 out of 5
3 days ago

Great Selection

Great selection of in store made breads, bagels, cookies, pies and cakes. Great service every town should have a buttercups.

Victor Feliciano | Local Guide
 Rated 5 out of 5
2 days ago

Great little “go to store”

Great little “go to store” for milk, eggs, bread, and many other grocery items. Deli cold cut counter always fresh and clean. Staff is great! Staple in the community. An old school feel. Luv it!

David R.

 Rated 5 out of 5
3 days ago

I love Buttercups !

I love Buttercups ! They made life fun and affordable with their lunch specials at a great price and quality while I attended school & I really appreciated that . Their bread was always so fluffy and people working were happy & it was always a lovely interaction. Thanks for being a yummy part of my days.

Earth F

 Rated 5 out of 5
3 days ago

Great Selection

Great selection of in store made breads, bagels, cookies, pies and cakes. Great service every town should have a buttercups.

Victor Feliciano | Local Guide
 Rated 5 out of 5
2 days ago

Great little “go to store”

Great little “go to store” for milk, eggs, bread, and many other grocery items. Deli cold cut counter always fresh and clean. Staff is great! Staple in the community. An old school feel. Luv it!

David R.

 Rated 5 out of 5
3 days ago

I love Buttercups !

I love Buttercups ! They made life fun and affordable with their lunch specials at a great price and quality while I attended school & I really appreciated that . Their bread was always so fluffy and people working were happy & it was always a lovely interaction. Thanks for being a yummy part of my days.

Earth F

Contact us

Buttercup’s Dairy Store
285 Boyle Rd
Port Jefferson Station, NY

Monday – Friday: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday – Sunday: 8:00 AM – 6:00 PM

(631) 928-4607

Ordering & Pickup

Call ahead to place your deli orders and check availability! (631) 928-4607

Subscribe For Weekly Updates

  • Shop Online
  • About Us
  • Visit
  • Shop Online
  • About Us
  • Visit
Copyright © 2026

Website by Art of Media Design

up

Inactive

New In

Fresh every day

Butcher

Organic meat

Dairy

Fresh quality taste

Fruits & Veg

Fresh from the garden

Bakery

Freshly baked

Seasonal Boxes

Seasonal selection

Inactive